The hunt is on for a solution to the cost of care

The myth that older people north of the border get off ‘Scot-free’ when it comes to paying for care is oft perpetuated, yet in truth a large care bill can cost you your home.  As Jeremy Hunt re-opens the debate in England, Age Scotland’s Callum Chomczuk asks ‘what next for Scotland?’

Ok most of you aren’t likely to be paying attention but this week Jeremy Hunt made in his first major speech since becoming Health Secretary at the Tory party conference in Birmingham.

He quite rightly highlighted the biggest priority for the NHS as meeting the challenges of an ageing population and as part of this agenda he would be looking to introduce the Dilnot proposals as soon as possible.

You have never heard if it? Alas you are not alone. Essentially this refers to the idea put forward last year by the economist Andrew Dilnot who called for a cap to be imposed on the residential care costs people face  and also for the  relaxing of capital threshold before means tested support is removed. What is means is that right now if you own your home then you will unlikely to be eligible for any support with residential care costs.

Now Mr Hunt’s his remit and power stops at Berwick (and for those of you who are just a bit sceptical of the healing power of homeopathy that may be a good thing). However that doesn’t mean that governments north and south of the border can’t learn from each other. 

In Scotland we are all quite rightly proud of Free Personal and Nursing Care but when we discuss the fact that free care is limited to a narrow prescribed list of support packages and that most care still has to be paid for (will we call this a tax on disability?), that those assessed eligible for care are legally allowed  to be placed on waiting lists if the council is a bit short of cash and that older people can be forced to sell their home to pay for long term residential care then we can get a bit sheepish about how great our care system is.

So where the UK Government is stealing a march on us in Scotland we should be big enough and ugly enough to take note and learn from their experience. 

While these proposal may get watered down they are at least at this point being debated in England. In Scotland our focus on health and social care integration threaten to distract us from the other aspects of the care system that are in vital need of reform.

But let’s be honest this isn’t going to be free and the issue for us all whether  a care cap is a good use of limited public  funds. However for me allowing people  to protect themselves against the risk of very high care costs and  the risk of losing all their assets, including their house is a policy worth pursuing. The question is do you feel the same?

Callum Chomczuk is Age Scotland’s Senior Policy and Parliamentary Officer.

2 thoughts on “The hunt is on for a solution to the cost of care

  1. I think most people are happy with the idea of some kind of cap. As a pensioner myself, I cannot see that those in work can foot a bill for care that is totally free. At the same time, demands on older people and their families can be huge. My Mum died very shortly after “free” personal care was introduced in Scotland. She spent her last 11 years in a nursing home. Her care and accommodation over the years cost our family around £250,000. The value of her house and most of my late Father’s life savings disappeared into the nursing home’s black hole. Because she wasn’t eligible for benefits, she paid a higher rate (for an identical service) than many of the other residents in the home who were on benefit. In other words, she had to subsidize other residents out of her own resources – so it was a double whammy. That never seemed fair to me.

    • Hi Alasdair. Thanks for your response, which I will share with Callum. It’s good to hear that our stance on a cap is finding support.

      Best Regards
      Doug Anthoney, communications team

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s